We’ve seen two comedies in the last couple of weeks, which couldn’t be more different from one another, but that had the (packed) Off-Broadway audiences laughing their fool heads off.
First up was The Cripple of Inishmaan a co-production of Druid Theatre Company and Atlantic Theater Company. If you’re familiar with Martin McDonagh’s work (The Beauty Queen of Leenane, The Lieutenant of Inishmore, The Lonesome West, A Skull in Connemara and The Pillowman on stage; In Bruges and Six Shooter on film), you know that despite his often grim (and frequently grisly) subject matter, he is, no kidding, one of the funniest playwrights working today. And Cripple is vintage McDonagh. The dialogue is crisp, the jokes are rapier sharp and, under Gerry Hynes’s direction at Atlantic, the cast is sublime.
A few days later we caught Enter Laughing at The York Theatre Company, which had an initial run in early fall and is being reprised through March 8. This musical, with a book by Joseph Stein and music and lyrics by Stan Daniels, is based on the play by Joseph Stein from the novel by Carl Reiner, is a classic screwball comedy, made for laughs and unashamedly played for laughs.
What struck me on both occasions is how truly wonderful the Off Broadway experience can be, particularly at a skillfully produced and performed comedy. It’s really something to sit in the dark, laughing and hearing everyone around you laughing at the same thing. The sound and energy just buoy you, and it’s extraordinary to feel the energy cascading back and forth between performers and audience, each propelling the other. Movies, even really funny ones, just can’t deliver the same punch, can they?